Firmus says data centre benefits ‘modest’ as it opposes major project status

The site would eventually hold 40 diesel backup generators storing up to 10,000 litres each. Image / Pulse (File)

Data centre developer Firmus says its planned Wesley Vale facility would bring only “relatively modest” economic benefits, as it fights a push by Latrobe Council for the project to be declared a major project.

The council asked Planning Minister Kerry Vincent in September to declare the data centre a major project, warning the state’s planning system was not equipped to assess the proposal.

Advertisement

After receiving the council’s request, Vincent asked Firmus for further information. In its response, Firmus argued the project did not meet any of the criteria needed for a declaration.

“The proponent does not consider the project to be eligible for declaration as a Major Project under section 60M,” the report said.

The facility would sit next to the Wesley Vale substation in Tasmania’s north-west. Image / Stock

It said the project “will not have a significant impact on or make a significant contribution to, the region’s economy” and “is not of strategic importance to the region”.

The report described the benefits as “relatively modest and largely confined to employment opportunities”.

A major project declaration would hand the assessment to the Tasmanian Planning Commission. Image / File

Firmus said the facility would employ about 25 permanent full-time staff once the first stage was operating and more than 70 local contractors would be engaged during construction.

Under the state’s planning laws, a project must meet at least two of three criteria to be declared a major project: a significant effect on the region’s economy, environment or social fabric, strategic importance to the region and scale and complexity.

Advertisement

A major project declaration would mean the proposal was assessed by an independent panel of the Tasmanian Planning Commission rather than by the council.

Firmus wants the project to continue to be assessed by Latrobe Council through the standard development application process.

Rainwater harvesting with 1,000 kilolitres of storage would help cool the Wesley Vale facility. Image / Pulse (File)

The council had hoped to decide the application in October. Latrobe Mayor Peter Freshney has said that if the application is sent back to the council, it will push for extra powers under the state planning rules.

The facility would have an initial capacity of about 26 megawatts, growing to about 52 megawatts.

Advertisement

Technical reports included with the proposal show the site would eventually have 40 diesel backup generators, with up to 30 operating at once, each storing up to 10,000 litres of diesel.

Firmus is working with the generator supplier to reduce the noise from each unit.

The development application included in the proposal lists an estimated cost of $31.25 million. The council has previously described the project as worth $2.1 billion.

The facility, on part of the former Wesley Vale pulp mill site next to the Wesley Vale substation, would have about 3,500 square metres of floor space, operate around the clock and use roof-mounted chillers and adiabatic cooling.

Advertisement

It would harvest rainwater with about 1,000 kilolitres of storage, including a 700-kilolitre cooling reserve, with trucked water as a backup.

Firmus said it had bought the land and ordered long-lead equipment, including backup power and cooling.

The development application lists an estimated cost of $31.25 million. Image / Stock

Firmus’ parent company, Firmus Grid, withdrew its planned ASX listing last month and is seeking private funding.

The company is also appealing to the Tasmanian Civil and Administrative Tribunal against George Town Council conditions limiting its use of diesel generators at its approved Bell Bay data centre.

Greens MP Vica Bayley said Firmus had “belted its own cat” by downplaying the economic benefits of its data centres.

“There’s limited jobs, there’s limited economic activity and there’s huge amounts of risk both for the Tasmanian budget and for the Tasmanian public,” he said.

Advertisement

Bayley said Firmus was “saying this to try to manage expectations and manage decisions around who actually assesses its project”.

Greens MP Vica Bayley said Firmus had “belted its own cat” over its data centre claims. Image / Pulse

The House of Assembly passed a Greens motion on Wednesday calling for a moratorium on new AI data centres larger than five megawatts.

View/Add a comment