Tasmanian firearm reforms pass upper house without caps on gun ownership

Registered firearms in Tasmania have risen from around 117,000 to around 152,000 since 2001. Image / Pulse (File)

Tasmania’s firearm law overhaul has cleared the Legislative Council without caps on gun ownership, after most upper house members signalled they would not support them.

The bill passed its third reading on voices this morning and will return to the House of Assembly to consider the upper house’s amendments.

Advertisement

Labor MLC Sarah Lovell did not move the cap she had planned to, after members voted nine to five against a related amendment.

She had told members that “whether or not members support this clause may depend on whether or not they intend to support the amendment for caps”.

Labor MLC Sarah Lovell moved the proposed cap on firearm ownership in the Legislative Council. Image / Pulse

The bill reclassifies centrefire straight-pull and button or lever release firearms as Category C, excludes family violence offenders from holding a firearm for 10 years and introduces mandatory minimum sentences for firearm theft.

The cap Lovell had planned to move would have limited licence holders to 10 firearms in total and five for recreational hunting or vermin control, with the Police Commissioner able to approve exemptions.

Police Commissioner Donna Adams could have approved exemptions under the proposed cap. Image / Pulse

The related amendment would have let people appeal to the Magistrates Court if the commissioner refused an exemption from a cap. Most members who spoke in the debate said they did not support caps.

A Labor amendment for the same cap failed 16 votes to 15 in the House of Assembly in September.

Advertisement

The upper house voted eight to six to create a new Category C licence for unpaid helpers, such as recreational shooters, who control pests on a primary producer’s land.

The licence covers one straight-pull centrefire firearm, which can be used only for pest control on that property with written permission from the person farming it. The number of licences is limited to three for properties under 800 hectares and five for larger properties.

The bill excludes family violence offenders from holding a firearm for 10 years. Image / Pulse (File)

Relatives of primary producers who live on or near the farm will also be able to use primary production as their reason for a Category C licence.

The bill will now return to the House of Assembly to consider the upper house’s amendments.

Advertisement

Lovell said nearly 9,000 Tasmanians held six or more firearms and about three in four licence holders had five or fewer and would not be affected.

“Fewer guns in the community means risk is reduced. More guns in the community increases the risk. That is a simple fact,” she said.

The Legislative Council voted down the gun cap proposal nine votes to five. Image / Pulse

“That a perfect line cannot be drawn is not a reason to draw no line at all.”

Greens MLC Cassy O’Connor said Police Commissioner Donna Adams had written to the police minister in February supporting a cap.

Advertisement

“Less guns, less public health risk, less death,” O’Connor said.

Independent Nelson MLC Meg Webb also supported the cap, saying it took a public health approach to “a lethal product”.

Independent Elwick MLC Bec Thomas said she was not convinced caps were the right approach. Image / Pulse

Independent Elwick MLC Bec Thomas said she was not convinced caps were the right approach.

“I do recognise that some in our community will be deeply upset by my decision not to support gun caps, but I would absolutely support further inquiry into this matter and consideration of what is occurring across other jurisdictions in Australia,” she said.

Independent Launceston MLC Rosemary Armitage said she did not believe there was compelling evidence for caps.

“Why should the cap be five? Why should it be 10? Why not four? Why not 15? What evidence demonstrates that one particular figure is safer than another?” she said.

Advertisement

Independent Murchison MLC Ruth Forrest said a cap could have a “perverse outcome” and “actually increase the number of firearms in the community”.

Leader for the Government in the Legislative Council Tania Rattray said the government considered caps “a solution in search of a problem”.

Labor MLC Sarah Lovell moved the proposed cap on firearm ownership in the Legislative Council. Image / Pulse (File)

She said registered firearms in Tasmania had risen from about 117,000 to about 152,000 since 2001, while firearm deaths had fallen as a proportion of the population.

Rattray said buyback negotiations with the federal government could not begin until the bill passed. She said previous, preliminary advice was that the Commonwealth would fund a fixed-price buyback, with payments depending on the type of firearm and capped at $1,000.

View/Add a comment