Parliament is expected to vote this afternoon on a Labor motion calling for a commission of inquiry into Tasmania’s health system, after the health minister again ruled one out.
The Australian Medical Association (AMA) called for the inquiry in October.
It said the system’s problems were connected and could not be fixed one at a time.
The nurses’ union, the Health and Community Services Union, the Greens and independent MP Craig Garland have since backed it.
Health Minister Bridget Archer says an inquiry would cost $30 million or more and that the most urgent problem is patients stuck in hospital waiting for aged care.

Labor leader Josh Willie told reporters Archer was siding with the treasurer over health workers.
“On one hand you have doctors, nurses, paramedics who want a commission of inquiry to improve the health system,” he said.
“On the other hand, you have Eric Abetz, who wants to cut $700 million from health.”
The state budget sets out about $702 million in savings for the health department over four years. The government says overall health spending is budgeted to rise.
In question time this morning, Willie used most of his questions to ask Archer about an inquiry.

Archer told parliament $30 million was “a conservative estimate” of what an inquiry might cost. The government spends about $10 million a day on health.
Willie twice asked whether she had received advice on what an inquiry would cost. The minister did not say.
“I would rather invest $30 million, $40 million, however many millions of dollars a commission of inquiry would be… into the direct healthcare that Tasmanians need,” she said.
Archer said an inquiry would replicate past and current inquiries, including one under way in the Legislative Council and that its supporters did not agree on what it should examine.

“You can outsource the inquiry, but you can’t outsource the decision-making,” she said.
Archer said the most critical issue facing the health system was the 142 patients stuck in Tasmania’s hospitals waiting for aged care or National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) places.
She said that was about 10% of major hospital beds and blamed the federal government.
“Why would I support an inquiry spending millions of dollars and taking years when I know what the problem is?” she said.
Outside the chamber, Willie said the federal government had “work to do” on aged care.

“But I’ll tell you what Tasmanians are sick of. They are sick of Bridget Archer, the health minister, blaming everybody else except for herself and failing to take responsibility for the state of our health service,” he said.
Labor MLC and shadow health minister Sarah Lovell told reporters there had been six health ministers under the Liberal government and none had turned the system around.
“What we don’t have and what we haven’t had is an inquiry that can bring all of those solutions together. That’s what we need,” she said.
“We need a plan that looks at the system as a whole.”
Lovell said the $30 million estimate was “an excuse” based on “no evidence” and reflected the cost of the last commission of inquiry, which examined every government department.
Lovell said a New South Wales inquiry into its much larger health system was projected to cost about $16 million.

That estimate was made before the inquiry began in 2023. It reported last year.
In question time, Archer said the NSW inquiry “specifically looked at funding to the health system” and was narrower in focus.
Greens leader Rosalie Woodruff told reporters her party supported an inquiry and there was “momentum building” for one.
“Any government should take the recommendations of a commission of inquiry seriously,” she said.

